Virtually no rebranding goes unnoticed. According to a recent Clutch study, a whopping 98% of consumers take note of brand changes. But being noticed isn’t the same as being liked: in fact, only roughly half of brand changes draw positive reactions from consumers, according to the same study.
On the one hand, fixing outdated or poor design or appealing to a new audience warrants rebranding. On the other hand, staying consistent comes with its own ROI: four out of five consumers actually pay attention to consistency when making purchasing decisions.
So, how do you make the right choice — and make sure your audience actually likes your new visual identity? Here’s your guide to the rebranding process.
TL;DR
Rebranding is a more profound change that involves overhauling both the brand strategy and visual identity.
Design refresh focuses on tweaking only the visual aspects of the product or brand.
Rebranding design is more suitable for outdated brands and businesses that pivot to new audiences, offerings, or markets.
Design refresh helps overcome issues with scaling to other channels or user experience.
What Rebranding Is & Isn’t
You might think that tweaking the color palette, switching a font, and removing sharp edges from buttons have all the markings of rebranding design. But all those changes are merely a design refresh. Unlike rebranding, they’re somewhat superficial and concern only the look of your product.
In fact, rebranding involves revisiting all components of your brand identity: strategy, positioning, messaging, architecture, tone and voice, and, of course, visual identity.
Think of a design refresh as cosmetic improvements to your house. Rebranding, in turn, is more like knocking down the walls, strengthening the foundation, and rebuilding the house on top of it.
How Do You Know If You Need One?
When to Opt for Rebranding Design
Rebranding is a massive, risky undertaking with implications for your whole business. How well you reinvent your brand can make or break future product adoption and user retention.
Rebranding design is worth it if:
Your brand doesn’t reflect your business anymore
You’ve realized your brand doesn’t help you stand out
You’re planning to expand your target audience or pivot to a new one
Your messaging is attracting the wrong audience
When to Opt for a Design Refresh
Unlike the rebranding process, a design refresh is simpler, less risky, and less expensive. But, of course, it’s not going to work in every single case. Opt for it if:
Your audience hasn’t changed in any substantial way
Your design doesn’t scale well (or at all) to other digital channels
User feedback indicates substantial UI/UX issues
Your brand identity is still relevant, but the visual identity feels outdated
How to Prepare for Rebranding
Your gut may be telling you your whole brand needs an overhaul. But, considering the inherent risks of rebranding, you need to back up that gut feeling with hard data.
So, before going all in on rebranding:
Conduct a brand audit. Review your brand strategy, positioning, and messaging. Do they still align with your long-term goals? How do customers feel about your brand?
Gather feedback. Collect Voice of the Customer data and conduct a UX audit for your product.
Know your audience. Different audiences pay attention to different brand signals. Make sure you have a full grasp of them before rebranding.
Analyze your competitors. Does your brand feel different from theirs? Does it feel outdated by comparison?
Your product has outgrown its design?
Remove sources of friction, boost UX metrics, and breathe new life into your brand with Fivecube’s comprehensive, data-driven product redesign services.
3 Components of Rebranding Design
3 Rebranding Design Mistakes to Avoid
Admittedly, a lot can go wrong during rebranding design. Your audience may not take to the new brand identity or scoff at the new logo. Just take Cracker Barrel as an example: its first logo change in 40 years sparked so much backlash that the chain had to walk back the change.
Here are the three mistakes that could lead to a similar rebranding fiasco:
Starting with visuals. Remember: the brand strategy is the foundation; so, your rebranding should start with revisiting it.
Relying (too much) on the gut feeling. Sometimes, the gut feeling can lead to a win. But often, it leads to a disastrous rebranding rejected by the audience.
Starting 100% from scratch. It’s rarely a good idea to pivot to a completely new brand identity: existing customers might consider it a betrayal of your original promise.
Final Thoughts
Rebranding isn’t done once you’ve sent out PR releases and informed your customers. After that, you’ll need to monitor its reception and refine your brand according to incoming feedback. So, make sure to track brand sentiment, sales and engagement metrics, and customer retention and acquisition.
Current product design isn’t living up to your objectives and user expectations? One of our clients, Intrac, came to us with this exact problem. Read our Intrac case study to discover how we enhanced product usability with a new information architecture and UI/UX design.
Mar 31, 2026
By
Fivecube Team
Previous Article
Want a tailored solution?
Let’s build something great together!